patching...
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

Latest Link: Hartland Township Trustees Lampooned Over Ending Water Fluoridation

Trustee leading charge to stop the practice said column that references 1964 comedy 'Dr. Strangelove' and the John Birch Society was funny.

 

The Hartland Township Board is the subject of an MLive.com column that satirizes its vote this week to stop adding fluoride to the township's drinking water.

The column by Jeff T. Wattrick writes the trustees "have thwarted a communist plot to sap and impurify the Livingston County community’s precious bodily fluids with their fluoridated water."

This seems to compare board members to Gen. Jack T. Ripper of the 1964 political satire Dr. Strangelove — whose famous YouTube clip on the subject is included (here, too).

Trustee Glenn Harper, who spearheaded efforts to stop adding fluoride, said "he got a real good chuckle out of it."

"Dr. Strangelove is one of my favorite movies," he said, although he added he hadn't thought about the connection during the recent debate because he hadn't seen the film in years.

Even the headline is a takeoff of the film: "Dr. Strangelove or how Hartland Township learned to stop fluoridating water and love cavities". The film's full title is: Dr. Strangelove or: How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Bomb.

The piece also touches on other fluoride conspiracy theories by saying trustees could face removal to Alaska, citing a belief by the late leader of the right-wing John Birch Society.

"Who is to say the federal government couldn’t reactivate this fluoride prison camp program to oppress these new 'Sons of Liberty' from humble Hartland?"

Harper said the column was just one reaction to the vote. He said some who are anti-fluoride do take liberty with the facts, but that shouldn't mean all arguments against fluoride should be discounted. He said he consulted primary sources such as the Centers for Disease Control and that still led him to support ending fluoridation.

"Our board went out of the way to look at both sides of the issue," he said. "The issue is settled in Hartland. … Hopefully, others will follow suit."

Related Topics: Conspiracy Theories, Dr. Strangelove, Hartland Township Board, John Birch Society, The Fluoride Debate in Hartland, fluoridation, and fluoride in drinking water
What do you think? Tell us in the comments.

pascal

2:38 pm on Friday, December 23, 2011

Thank you to all councillors who have the intelligence of challenging the status quo and reading the modern peer reviewed scientific research showing many ill effects of fluoride. Having the courage to stop a long practise such as this, is a proof that one loves life and your fellow neighbours. Thank you to all of you who helped stop fluoride:) Your sons and great sons will be proud of their grand parents :)

Reply

jwillie6

4:34 pm on Friday, December 23, 2011

What a silly article. As the old saying goes, when you don't have the facts, you call people names like Dr. Strangelove or communists.

Read the truth produced in the best scientific information on fluoridation here: (www.fluoridealert.org). You will see a petition signed by almost 4000 professionals, including hundreds of dentists, hundreds of doctors, and other medical researchers calling on governments everywhere to stop fluoridation.

There are many large scientific studies there to show that drinking fluoridated water has no positive effect on cavity reduction and to show that it causes cancer, thyroid damage, broken hips from brittle bones, lowered IQ and other health problems.

Reply

dan rice

4:38 pm on Friday, December 23, 2011

I (and others) will save my thank you to the board for the next election.

Reply

Paul Connett

7:59 am on Saturday, December 24, 2011

Rather than resolving the water fluoridation issue based upon a movie made in 1964, how about doing so using a book written in 2010? Since I co-authored this text, "The Case Against Fluoride" (Chelsea Green), with two other scientists I have been waiting for a scientific response from fluoridation promoters. After 14 months there has been none. Instead we get treated to rants about Dr. Strangelove. There are 80 pages of references to the scientific literature in our book. We had hoped that our book would raise the level of this debate but the promoters don't appear to want to do that. Why not?
Paul Connett, PhD

Reply

Leave a comment